Jump to Navigation
Over 30 Years of Experience handling tax controversies & tax disputes

Speculation abounds as to how the Supreme Court will rule

In a prior post, we highlighted the question of how broad the term “obstruction of justice” could be construed in the context of bringing criminal charges for continuing failures to file federal tax returns. We noted that the owner of a freight service company was indicted on nine counts of tax related offenses, including a violation of Section 7212(a) of the Tax Code, which calls for criminal sanctions upon anyone who “corruptly…obstructs or impedes or endeavors to obstruct or impede the due administration of the Internal Revenue Code.”

According to comments in a recent accountingtoday.com report, the section is affectionately termed a “one-man conspiracy statute.” Of course, anyone versed in the basics of criminal law will understand that a conspiracy takes two or more persons, but with the Tax Code, apparently that is not the case. As such, it has been a potent weapon for prosecutors to bring charges in cases such as the one involving the freight service company owner. 

The U.S. Supreme Court recently heard the case to resolve disagreements among appellate courts( particularly the Sixth Circuit and Second Circuit) as to whether Section 7217(a) requires a defendant to knowingly interfere with a pending investigation.  Now the speculation begins on how the court will rule.

Many who are reading the tea leaves believe that the Court will reverse and remand the case back to the Second Circuit with a new standard of review given the reaction of the justices during oral argument. Many of them were concerned about just how broad the IRS could interpret the statute to criminalize almost any action.

Nevertheless the story is a prime example of why it is critical to have an experienced tax law attorney when facing criminal charges. 

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Have a Question? Ask an Attorney:

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

Visit Our
Tax Law Website
Contact Information

Levins Tax Law, LLC
1671 Worcester Road, Suite 304
Framingham, MA 01701

Framingham Law Office Map

Levins Tax Law, LLC
38 Newbury Street, 6th Floor
Boston, MA 02116

Boston Law Office Map
By Appointment Only

Phone: 508-435-0118
Toll-Free: 888-333-9501
Fax: 888-333-0291